Synaptic Sparks icon image

Material Evidence & Logical Proof

Synaptic Sparks
Home
Main Table of Contents
Comment on this page
Discussion Forum
Legal Warning page
Law lookup links

The material evidence on this page is a quote of a directive interpreting a law. This directive is stated in the form of:

If A, Then B.

 The obverse logic is irrefutable and it states:

If not A, Then not B.

I expect cognitive dissonance will be triggered for some of you when you understand what A and B represent.


Do you "believe" you have to file an IRS Form 1040 every year because the law says soMost of you who have that "belief" are wrong. A few of you are correct.

Do you "believe" I have to file an IRS Form 1040 every year because the law says so? All of you who have that "belief" are wrong. I've actually read the law with my own two eyes. That's why I know that I don't have to file an IRS Form 1040.

The material evidence and logical proof supporting the prior paragraph now follows:


The material evidence: The instructions for IRS Form 1040, which have not changed in several years, state:

Our legal right to ask for information is Internal Revenue Code sections 6001, 6011, and 6012(a), and their regulations. They say that you must file a return or statement with us for any tax you are liable for. Your response is mandatory under these sections.

(A more detailed study of the laws cited can be examined deeper in this website.)

The logical proof:

  • The above quotation of the Form 1040 instructions tell me that I must file a return for any (income) tax I am "liable" for.
  • The above quotation does not tell me that I must file a return for any (income) tax I am not "liable" for.
  • Therefore, My response is not mandatory if I am not "liable" for any (income) tax".
  • Therefore, I am not required to file a return if there is no mechanism or law that makes me "liable" for the (income) tax". (A "mechanism" itself must also be a creation of "law", Therefore, "What law makes me liable for the income tax?" is still the valid question.)
  • After several years of studying the Internal Revenue Code and the applicable Code of Federal Regulations, I have not found any law that specifically makes me liable for the "income" tax. An example of a law making a person liable for the "distilled spirits" tax is shown below.
  • What has been presented to me by the Status Quo Brigade as the laws that make me liable for the "income" tax does not meet the standards of material evidence and logical proof and that faulty answer will be specifically addressed later.
  • Therefore, since I am not made liable for an "income" tax on what I am paid in compensation for my labor, I am not required to fill out the 1040 income tax form.

prudent person who knows that the requirement to file a Form 1040 is based upon being liable for an income tax would want to know the mechanism or law that makes them bona fide liable for an income tax.  


What law makes me liable for the income tax?

If the question was "What law makes me liable for the distilled spirits tax?", the question could be quickly answered - "Section 5005."

TITLE 26 - INTERNAL REVENUE CODE
Subtitle E - Alcohol, Tobacco, and Certain Other Excise Taxes
CHAPTER 51 - DISTILLED SPIRITS, WINES, AND BEER
Subchapter A - Gallonage and Occupational Taxes
PART I - GALLONAGE TAXES
Subpart A - Distilled Spirits

Sec. 5005. Persons liable for tax
(a) General
The distiller or importer of distilled spirits shall be liable for the taxes imposed thereon by section 5001(a)(1).

My dictionary defines "liable" as "Legally obligated; responsible". Therefore, clearly, the above quoted Code Section is stating: 

The distiller or importer of distilled spirits shall be legally obligated for payment of the distilled spirits taxes imposed...

The imposition of a liability is the imposition of a legal obligation. If the obligation is not imposed, the obligation does not exist. 

As proven above, If someone is not "liable" for an income tax, Then someone is not required to file a Form 1040. Therefore, What law makes me liable for the income tax? is a very important question.


When asked, "What law makes me liable for the income tax?" the IRS does not answer the question and state the law. Instead, the IRS threatens, ignores, and evades. The IRS has REFUSED (note) to directly and concisely answer this and other very important questions asked by myself and others. Consider these points of logic:

  • The IRS can NOT answer this question IF there is no law imposing liability for the income tax.
  • If there is a law imposing this liability, then the IRS would be able to quell the rising tide of people asking the question, by simply doing what I did with the 5005 distilled spirits liability section. Would a reasonable person argue that there is no law imposing liability and legal obligation to pay the distilled spirits tax?

"The law must be there somewhere" is a belief based not upon material evidence and logical proof, but upon a lie accepted as true.

"The law must be there somewhere" is what the IRS wants you to "believe", so that you don't go looking for this law that the IRS refuses to identify.

If you make the statement, "The law must be there somewhere", then you have issued a lie, passing it along like a person does a rumor heard and mindlessly repeated at a water fountain.

If the preceding is what you "believe", I challenge you to cure your ignorance by using this computer you are sitting in front of to find exactly WHERE the law actually is that "must be there somewhere."

If you can prove your "belief" correct, then you can prove me wrong. If you can not prove your "belief" correct, then you will have proven me correct.

When you fail to prove your "belief" correct, you will have then verified for yourself that the law establishing liability for the income tax does not exist.


BUT WAIT! THERE'S MORE!

The above cited material evidence is only the beginning of challenging the common (albeit erroneous) "belief" regarding the income tax. The above evidence does not stand alone. There is much more to be shown to you if you have the courage to look with an open mind. 

I have courage.                          I'm a coward

Document made with Nvu
November 2008